Skip to content Skip to navigation

Conventions

Blog entry

The Theory of Related-ivity:

A History and Analysis of the Best Related Work Hugo Category

by Heather Rose Jones

(This is a serialized article exploring the history of the Best Related Work Hugo category in its various names and versions. If you’ve come in at the middle, start here.)

Contents

Part 2: Methodology

2.3 Data and Eligibility

2.3.1 Data Sources and Available Data

The Theory of Related-ivity:

A History and Analysis of the Best Related Work Hugo Category

by Heather Rose Jones

(This is a serialized article exploring the history of the Best Related Work Hugo category in its various names and versions. If you’ve come in at the middle, start here.)

Contents

Part 2: Methodology

2.2 Overlapping Categories

2.2.1 Introduction

2.2.2 Fancast

The Theory of Related-ivity:

A History and Analysis of the Best Related Work Hugo Category

by Heather Rose Jones

(This is a serialized article exploring the history of the Best Related Work Hugo category in its various names and versions. If you’ve come in at the middle, start here.)

Contents

Part 2: Methodology

2.1 Administrative History

2.1.1 Introduction

2.1.2 Summary Timeline

The Theory of Related-ivity:

A History and Analysis of the Best Related Work Hugo Category

by Heather Rose Jones

(This is a serialized article exploring the history of the Best Related Work Hugo category in its various names and versions.)

Contents

Part 1: Background

1.1 Author’s Preface

1.2 Introduction and Definitions

1.3 Prior Analyses


Part 1: Background

I have a hard time splitting my attention sufficiently to blog during a convention -- I often barely remember to post on social media. But now that it's Monday and I'm having breakfast in my hotel room with a couple hours before I need to be at the train station to go home, let's see if I can remember enough details.

Planning to be at Seattle Worldcon? Want to know what I'm doing there? Check out my schedule!

After the flurry of postings in the last month, I'm taking a brief break for the holiday weekend. In fact, the "On the Shelf" podcast episode will be delayed probably until Tuesday, since I'm not going to try to record it in a hotel room. (I'm currently at BayCon/Westercon.) If you're at the con, make sure to find me and say hi.

The Hugo Award finalists were just annouced, so I can finally go public. In the category of Best Related Work, the essay "Charting the Cliff: An Investigation Into the 2023 Hugo Nomination Statistics" by Camestros Felapton and Heather Rose Jones received enough nominations to be on the final Hugo Awards ballot.

More details to come.

Purpose

The recent announcement from the Glasgow Worldcon committee about some unexpected patterns in Hugo voting ballots, the conclusions made about those patterns, and the actions taken in response, have naturally raised interest in the nomination process for this year. As readers may remember, both the nomination process and voting process in 2023 had clear anomalies that cast severe doubt on the validity of the outcome and generated a great deal of concern among the SFF community.

The analysis I did in two previous blogs (part 1, part 2) has been incorporated into a much broader and more detailed analysis by Camestros Felapton, and published under both our names (but be aware that he did a much larger proportion of the work).

Pages

Subscribe to Conventions
historical